Click here to close
New Message Alert
List Entire Thread
Msg ID: 2812098 Vy vs VToss +1/-1     
Author:Define
4/17/2024 12:58:22 PM

I'm having a hard time understanding the difference between Vy and Vtoss, when to use either one and which one gets you away from the ground, or over an obstacle the quickest



Reply  Return-To-Index  
 
Msg ID: 2812100 Vy is best rate. Vtoss is best angle (Vx) for helicopters (NT) +0/-5     
Author:Anonymous
4/17/2024 1:17:17 PM

Reply to: 2812098


Reply  Return-To-Index  
 
Msg ID: 2812116 Vy is best rate. Vtoss is best angle (Vx) for helicopters +6/-2     
Author:Not Necessarily Correct...
4/17/2024 5:49:33 PM

Reply to: 2812100

Vtoss is the designated airspeed in which a Part 29 transport category aircraft can be guaranteed to fly away OEI.  This value is based upon TAS, PA,TAT, and aircraft GW.  All these variables are dynamic.

v/r



Reply  Return-To-Index  
 
Msg ID: 2812317 Vy is best rate. Vtoss is best angle (Vx) for helicopters (NT) +0/-0     
Author:Who would downvote this one?
4/20/2024 3:56:51 PM

Reply to: 2812116


Reply  Return-To-Index  
 
Msg ID: 2812127 Vy is best rate. Vtoss is best angle (Vx) for helicopters +1/-3     
Author:WRONG
4/17/2024 7:42:39 PM

Reply to: 2812100

VX in a helicopter is straight up. 



Reply  Return-To-Index  
 
Msg ID: 2812129 straight up is not a Vspeed (NT) +0/-1     
Author:Anonymous
4/17/2024 8:01:01 PM

Reply to: 2812127


Reply  Return-To-Index  
 
Msg ID: 2812140 straight up is not a Vspeed +1/-1     
Author:You are misunderstood
4/17/2024 10:27:03 PM

Reply to: 2812129

VX is best angle of climb. 0 is a speed. Helicopters can climb straight up. This is indeed semantics but if you want to assume the power is unavailable to climb straight up then I suppose a greater VX speed around the range of VY exists. 

Show me anywhere where a helicopter section 5 publishes a VX speed. My above reply is precisely why. 



Reply  Return-To-Index  
 
Msg ID: 2812222 Um, if Vx is straight up (zero), then Vtoss is zero too! (NT) +0/-0     
Author:goes without saying!
4/18/2024 11:47:09 PM

Reply to: 2812127


Reply  Return-To-Index  
 
Msg ID: 2812713 Is Vtoss ever zero? (NT) +0/-0     
Author:Anonymous
4/26/2024 11:28:58 AM

Reply to: 2812222


Reply  Return-To-Index  
 
Msg ID: 2812103 Vy vs VToss +10/-0     
Author:Answer
4/17/2024 1:24:47 PM

Reply to: 2812098
Vy is best rate of climb. Maintain to reach desired altitude in the least amount of time. It will also be your maximum endurance speed, to give you the most time orbiting (not to be confused with max range). Vtoss is takeoff safety speed, specifically for multi engine aircraft. If you lose an engine above Vtoss, you (in theory) can continue takeoff and fly away. Losing an engine below Vtoss would result in being forced to land. Both speeds change based on weight and density altitude.


Reply  Return-To-Index  
 
Msg ID: 2812104 Vy vs VToss +0/-0     
Author:oldNtired
4/17/2024 1:47:01 PM

Reply to: 2812103

Related to V1 in fixedwing ?  (Category  A) take off , in a multiengine Helicopter ?  Honest question, just curious. ? 



Reply  Return-To-Index  
 
Msg ID: 2812137 Vy vs VToss +0/-0     
Author:No not V1
4/17/2024 10:22:56 PM

Reply to: 2812104

Vtoss would not be similar to V1. Fixed wing have a Vtoss as well, it is not a helicopter specific speed. Vtoss in fw would usually be maintained on an engine failure after V1 until obstacle clearance or a flap retraction altitude on first segment climb gradient.

V1 would not have a relationship with the helicopter world. 



Reply  Return-To-Index  
 
Msg ID: 2812248 You are referring to V2 (NT) +0/-0     
Author:Anonymous
4/19/2024 1:05:20 PM

Reply to: 2812137


Reply  Return-To-Index  
 
Msg ID: 2812106 Vy vs VToss +6/-0     
Author:The most
4/17/2024 2:39:06 PM

Reply to: 2812103

Wow somebody that actually had a valid answer to a question on this website good job



Reply  Return-To-Index  
 
Msg ID: 2812108 Vy vs VToss +0/-2     
Author:Vtoss
4/17/2024 4:05:22 PM

Reply to: 2812098

Vtoss gives you steepest climb gradient. Not to be confused with rate of climb.



Reply  Return-To-Index  
 
Msg ID: 2812111 Siimilar to Vxse (NT) +0/-0     
Author:Anonymous
4/17/2024 4:58:41 PM

Reply to: 2812108


Reply  Return-To-Index  
 
Msg ID: 2812126 Vy vs VToss +8/-0     
Author:Answer
4/17/2024 7:41:41 PM

Reply to: 2812098

First off Vtoss is strictly a twin engine term. It's the speed at which you have single engine fly away power to continue to accelerate to VY. Vtoss is on the back side of the power curve below VY so it's not the most efficient speed. Vtoss is not a speed isually intended to linger at unless first segment climb procedures specify vtoss as a procedural speed until obstacle clearance. Think of it as a marker for single engine fly away capability to transtition to VY or greater. Below Vtoss single engine fly away is not guaranteed considering your AGL height. 

 

VY is best rate of climb as we all know, least drag etc. In all helicopters VY is the bottom of the power curve. Always and forever.

 

If you want obstacle clearance VY is your best bet, or consider a speed between Vtoss and VY for obstacle clearance.


Technically speaking VX, or best angle, in a helicopter is straight up...

 



Reply  Return-To-Index  
 
Msg ID: 2812139 straight up is not a Vspeed (NT) +0/-2     
Author:Anonymous
4/17/2024 10:24:11 PM

Reply to: 2812126


Reply  Return-To-Index  
 
Msg ID: 2812141 straight up is not a Vspeed +1/-0     
Author:Again
4/17/2024 10:27:48 PM

Reply to: 2812139

VX is best angle of climb. 0 is a speed. Helicopters can climb straight up. This is indeed semantics but if you want to assume the power is unavailable to climb straight up then I suppose a greater VX speed around the range of VY exists. 

 

Show me anywhere where a helicopter section 5 publishes a VX speed. My above reply is precisely why. 



Reply  Return-To-Index  
 
Msg ID: 2812142 Some helicopter cannot climb straight up! (NT) +0/-1     
Author:especially OEI
4/17/2024 10:28:59 PM

Reply to: 2812141


Reply  Return-To-Index  
 
Msg ID: 2812164 Some helicopter cannot climb straight up! +2/-0     
Author:Obviously
4/18/2024 10:27:21 AM

Reply to: 2812142

Wether or not the aircraft is capable is not the point. Some helicopters can't hover OEI either. I think you need a masterclass. 



Reply  Return-To-Index  
 
Msg ID: 2812208 so, then, straight up isn't Vx! Vx would be above Vtoss and (NT) +0/-0     
Author:below Vy.
4/18/2024 8:09:11 PM

Reply to: 2812164


Reply  Return-To-Index  
 
Msg ID: 2812217 so, then, straight up isn't Vx! Vx would be above Vtoss and +0/-0     
Author:Get a refund from your flight school
4/18/2024 9:38:29 PM

Reply to: 2812208

So let's see, you are surrounded by 200 foot obstacles, what is your best angle of climb? (VX)

What is the best angle of climb in an F16?

I think your flight school did you a major disservice.

Tell me what helicopter FM publishes a VX speed??????? Answer: None

As I said before VX in helicopter is semantics because of the obvious fact you can't  seem to understand.



Reply  Return-To-Index  
 
Msg ID: 2812220 Um, if you can't climb straight up, you don't go! +0/-0     
Author:Vx is Vx, obstacles or not!
4/18/2024 11:24:22 PM

Reply to: 2812217

Vx is a speed, not a chart to tell you that you can clear an obstacle!  

You might not be able to climb at zero airspeed, but can at some airspeed above zero, or don't you remember that from flight school?   When you hit LTE, suddenly, you have lots of lift and can climb far better than you can at zero airspeed.

Maybe your too young to remember that technique getting out of a tight LZ.

Vx is the best climb gradient speed for a distance over the ground.

Vtoss is the minimum speed that give you a climb (not necessarily the best for a given distance).

Vy is the best rate in a given amount of time.

 

 



Reply  Return-To-Index  
 
Msg ID: 2812225 Um, if you can't climb straight up, you don't go! +0/-0     
Author:You need a lesson
4/19/2024 12:22:30 AM

Reply to: 2812220

Completely going off on tangents now are you? As I said already and now right out of the FAA book...

It says "the best angle of climb speed VX depends on the power available, if there is excess power available the helicopter can climb straight up, so VX is zero"

Precisely what I said in my posts before. You're welcome for the lesson...



Reply  Return-To-Index  
 
Msg ID: 2812240 You said, earlier, Vx is straight up! as if it was universal! +0/-0     
Author:Now you are agreeing with me,
4/19/2024 10:39:45 AM

Reply to: 2812225

as if you didn't say that!   Vx is calculated by the conditions, from the Obstacle Clearance charts!



Reply  Return-To-Index  
 
Msg ID: 2812221 Vx! +0/-0     
Author:Anonymous
4/18/2024 11:41:22 PM

Reply to: 2812217

https://youtu.be/MlFUMVSGgfY?t=273

 

https://www.faa.gov/sites/faa.gov/files/regulations_policies/handbooks_manuals/aviation/helicopter_flying_handbook/hfh_ch07.pdf

Page 7-7



Reply  Return-To-Index  
 
Msg ID: 2812223 Yes did you read it?? (NT) +0/-0     
Author:Precisely proves my state,ent
4/19/2024 12:13:07 AM

Reply to: 2812221


Reply  Return-To-Index  
 
Msg ID: 2812226 Your statement? That there is a Vx that is not zero?? +0/-0     
Author:Then yes, it proves it!
4/19/2024 12:50:14 AM

Reply to: 2812223

If the helicopter does not have the power to climb vertically, than Vx is some number at or above Vtoss!



Reply  Return-To-Index  
 
Msg ID: 2812228 Your statement? That there is a Vx that is not zero?? +0/-0     
Author:Did you read my original reply??!!
4/19/2024 1:08:44 AM

Reply to: 2812226

As I said before in case you missed it...

"VX is best angle of climb. 0 is a speed. Helicopters can climb straight up. This is indeed semantics but if you want to assume the power is unavailable to climb straight up then I suppose a greater VX speed around the range of VY exists. "

I clearly stated the exception of power was not available.

Again, you're welcome.

Read the threads first, read again, comprehend, reply. That order: 



Reply  Return-To-Index  
 
Msg ID: 2812224 Sorry fat fingered Yes did you read it??  +1/-0     
Author:Precisely proves my statement
4/19/2024 12:16:01 AM

Reply to: 2812221

It says "the best angle of climb speed VX depends on the power available, if there is excess power available the helicopter can climb straight up, so VX is zero"

You're very welcome.



Reply  Return-To-Index  
 
Msg ID: 2812227 Your statement was that Vx *is* zero! Not necessarily true!  +0/-0     
Author:My statement was that
4/19/2024 12:56:46 AM

Reply to: 2812224

Vtoss was Vx for helicopters.   Someone (you?) said "WRONG"

If Vx is zero because it has power to climb vertically.  Then Vx is zero, but so too is Vtoss.

Vtoss is the minimum speed to effect any climb

Vx is the speed to effect the best climb gradient.

Vy is the speed to effect the best rate of climb.

 

Vx and Vtoss can both be zero, but not always!  You said Vx was zero since a helicopter can climb vertically.  Nonsense!



Reply  Return-To-Index  
 
Msg ID: 2812229 Your statement was that Vx *is* zero! Not necessarily true!  +0/-0     
Author:Read and comprehend
4/19/2024 1:10:01 AM

Reply to: 2812227

As I said before in case you missed it...

"VX is best angle of climb. 0 is a speed. Helicopters can climb straight up. This is indeed semantics but if you want to assume the power is unavailable to climb straight up then I suppose a greater VX speed around the range of VY exists. "

I clearly stated the exception of power was not available.

Again, you're welcome.

Read the threads first, read again, comprehend, reply. That order.



Reply  Return-To-Index  
 
Msg ID: 2812237 Well, that's not what you said, but I give you credit for effort! +0/-2     
Author:Here's your post!
4/19/2024 9:10:28 AM

Reply to: 2812229

 

http://originalforum.justhelicopters.com/DisplayMsgJH.asp?ForumID=23&Msgid=2812127&page=1&title=Vy%20is%20best%20rate.%20%20Vtoss%20is%20best%20angle%20(Vx)%20for%20helicopters

 



Reply  Return-To-Index  
 
Msg ID: 2812289 Well, that's not what you said, but I give you credit for effort! +0/-0     
Author:VX is indeed striaght up
4/19/2024 10:17:35 PM

Reply to: 2812237

It's a true statement that VX is straight up, so I guess you live on a different planet than all the rest of us.

 

You're really making yourself look like a fool.



Reply  Return-To-Index  
 
Msg ID: 2812295 Not for this aircraft! +0/-0     
Author:Vx is about 20 kts
4/19/2024 11:54:07 PM

Reply to: 2812289

 

http://www.fortwolters.com/FW%20-%20Flipbooks/TH-55%20Manual/mobile/index.html#p=87

 

 



Reply  Return-To-Index  
 
Msg ID: 2812424 Not for this aircraft! +0/-0     
Author:You’re still not reading
4/21/2024 5:14:35 PM

Reply to: 2812295

Wow you guys just are misunderstood. So nowhere in this example you've given is VX given. 30 kias is listed as a best climb out speed to clear an obstacle, which as I said before if the power is unavailable for straight up a speed greater than 0 may be your "VX" 

If power is available, and you're surrounded by 100' obstacles that prevent an airspeed over altitude departure, what is your VX??????  Answer: VX is 0 or as I said before straight up...

 



Reply  Return-To-Index  
 
Msg ID: 2812437 Vx.... Best angle = shortest distance over ground +0/-0     
Author:Calculated with chart!
4/21/2024 10:55:05 PM

Reply to: 2812424

Chart shows that it is above ETL.  Somewhere about 18 kts.  Clearly not at 0 kts!

At MGW, Vx is not zero!

 



Reply  Return-To-Index  
 
Msg ID: 2812538 Vx.... Best angle = shortest distance over ground +0/-0     
Author:Embarrassed
4/23/2024 4:17:10 PM

Reply to: 2812437

This is why I can't be in this industry sector anymore with amateurs like you who are too dumb to even understand you're wrong. You all need a lesson in aerodynamics. What CFI taught you newbies? Not to menation you can't read and comprehend either.

The helo crowd will always be substandard because you don't understand your trade



Reply  Return-To-Index  
 
Msg ID: 2812542 You sound dangerous! +0/-0     
Author:Look at this chart.....
4/23/2024 5:02:04 PM

Reply to: 2812538

Notice, in Example B for various climbout airspeeds, above 10ft max hover ht, all the airspeeds converge at about 25 kts.  The 10, 15, 20 all merge into the 25 airspeed line!

Because that is Vx to clear an obstacle.

 

https://www.docdroid.com/otIUUww/bell-uh-1h-iroquois-flight-manual-pdf#page=353

 

Even if you have a max hover height of 25 ft, to clear a 25ft obstacle demands need about 360ft to clear the obstacle.   You will wind up in the trees if you fly slower than that calculated Vx

Speaking of aerodynamics....  when you hover, does it demand more power to maintain AGL at 0 KIAS or at 10KIAS?   How about 15KIAS?   When does the power required to maintain a hover decrease??  ETL!   Is ETL ever 0?   Nope.  What happens if you pull into a HOGE and accelerate with a fixed power setting??  You lose altitude!  

HAA operators demand you have HOGE +10% TQ.   That's a luxury.   But, your better performance is some airspeed above 0 to clear an obstacle!  And, all the performance charts back that up!  They might not call it Vx, but that's what it is!



Reply  Return-To-Index  
 
Msg ID: 2812451 straight up is not a Vspeed +0/-0     
Author:Slug
4/22/2024 8:46:23 AM

Reply to: 2812141

When confronted with high DA, high altitudes, high temps, gross weight take offs, the ability to go vertical may have been reduced to hover either in ground effect or hopefully just outside of ground effect.  If your obstacle is say 200'-500' then your ability to just go vertical has been removed.  Hence the Vy and Vtoss.  Vtoss for multiple engine aircraft to enable OEI while maintaining climb capabilities.   



Reply  Return-To-Index  
 
Msg ID: 2812454 Agreed, but remember, Vtoss is a multi-engine speed. +0/-0     
Author:A single-engine doesn't have Vtoss
4/22/2024 9:31:26 AM

Reply to: 2812451

Vtoss is equivelent to Vx(se) in fixed-wing aircraft.

A multi-engine aircraft can have a Vx when both engines are operating (AEI) for the situation you described above.

 

 



Reply  Return-To-Index  
 
Msg ID: 2812467 straight up is not a Vspeed +0/-0     
Author:So
4/22/2024 11:09:23 AM

Reply to: 2812451

Vtoss = takeoff safety speed but implies nothing more

Vx = Best angle 📐 of climb - no guarantees

Vy = Best rate of climb - no guarantees

None guarantee obstruction clearance; figure that yourself via WAT and wind to ground speed conditions

Buyer beware 



Reply  Return-To-Index  
 
Msg ID: 2812471 All of those speeds have charts showing distance to clear (NT) +0/-0     
Author:obstacles! "Distance Required" charts!
4/22/2024 12:36:22 PM

Reply to: 2812467


Reply  Return-To-Index  
 
Msg ID: 2814269 Vy vs VToss +0/-0     
Author:Almost
5/1/2024 10:09:35 PM

Reply to: 2812126

Ur close.........



Reply  Return-To-Index  
 
Msg ID: 2812195 Vy vs VToss +0/-1     
Author:OG
4/18/2024 5:33:44 PM

Reply to: 2812098

Vtoss is only confusing when you try and get a precise answer on this forum. Go the the FAAs definitions and your specific multiengine aircraft AFM>



Reply  Return-To-Index  
 
Msg ID: 2812210 Vy vs VToss +1/-0     
Author:TG
4/18/2024 8:25:46 PM

Reply to: 2812195

This is my take on the subject.

Vy: Best rate of climb, speed for minimum power, sum of all drags at a minimum (bucket speed), typically flown 60-80 KIAS depending on aircraft frontal area/size/drag factor. 

Vtoss/Vx: Best angle of climb, slight back side of the power curve, lower value than Vy, typically 40-50 KIAS depending on aircraft frontal area/size/drag factor. 

Both Vy and Vtoss are typically flown at the maximum power available.

Vy: Think POWER/DRAG (i.e. the aircraft climbs to altitude fast, pilot is exploiting the minimum drag acting on the aircraft while applying maximum power).

Vtoss: Think POWER/MAIN ROTOR THRUST (i.e. the aircraft climbs steeper, pilot is maximizing the main rotor thrust vector at maximum power). 



Reply  Return-To-Index  
 
Msg ID: 2812251 Vy vs VToss +0/-0     
Author:yeah
4/19/2024 2:42:28 PM

Reply to: 2812195

check the definitions in the regs



Reply  Return-To-Index  
 
Msg ID: 2812290 Vy vs VToss +0/-0     
Author:Yes if
4/19/2024 10:19:01 PM

Reply to: 2812195

Yes it's hard when you don't know who to listen to.



Reply  Return-To-Index