Click here to close
New Message Alert
List Entire Thread
Msg ID: 2804672 AEL Crash, OK...NTSB prelim is out, (NT) +2/-3     
Author:Geese
2/2/2024 7:43:12 PM


Reply  Return-To-Index  
 
Msg ID: 2804691 AEL Crash, OK...NTSB prelim is out, +9/-1     
Author:Anonymous
2/3/2024 7:18:08 AM

Reply to: 2804672

"the investigator said several dead geese were found near the crash site in an open pasture in rural western Oklahoma. The carcass of another goose was found embedded in a mechanism that controls the movement of flight control surfaces."

That's pretty defining right there.  



Reply  Return-To-Index  
 
Msg ID: 2804710 AEL Crash, OK...NTSB prelim is out, +1/-1     
Author:Anonymous
2/3/2024 10:38:00 AM

Reply to: 2804672

https://data.ntsb.gov/carol-repgen/api/Aviation/ReportMain/GenerateNewestReport/193686/pdf



Reply  Return-To-Index  
 
Msg ID: 2804712 AEL Crash, OK...NTSB prelim is out, +4/-1     
Author:Anonymous
2/3/2024 11:21:47 AM

Reply to: 2804672

So much for the arm chair investigators here that said main rotor blade loss. 



Reply  Return-To-Index  
 
Msg ID: 2804716 AEL Crash, OK...NTSB prelim is out, +0/-1     
Author:Gigantasaurus > Sue
2/3/2024 1:18:42 PM

Reply to: 2804712

"The carcasses of several geese were located in the debris field as well as one embedded in a
flight control servo"

How does a carcas become "embedded" in the actual servo. Thats nuts.



Reply  Return-To-Index  
 
Msg ID: 2804747 AEL Crash, OK...NTSB prelim is out, +2/-1     
Author:Ready to retire
2/4/2024 10:23:36 AM

Reply to: 2804672

40 years of flying and I sure as hell miss my double pane heating glass S-76 windshield.

The saddest part of all is most of the transfers today are bs patients not in need of rapid transport. Critical care maybe, however put em in a bus.

Special Ops war hero.....taken out by an effing bird.



Reply  Return-To-Index  
 
Msg ID: 2804749 Didn’t airlog or phi loose a 76 years ago hitting (NT) +0/-1     
Author:birds in the swamp?
2/4/2024 11:32:27 AM

Reply to: 2804747


Reply  Return-To-Index  
 
Msg ID: 2804754 Didn’t airlog or phi loose a 76 years ago hitting +2/-1     
Author:Yes
2/4/2024 12:50:18 PM

Reply to: 2804749

It was PHI, bird came threw glass and caused overhead throttles to retard to engine idle.



Reply  Return-To-Index  
 
Msg ID: 2804759 Didn’t airlog or phi loose a 76 years ago hitting (NT) +0/-1     
Author:Plastic
2/4/2024 2:14:10 PM

Reply to: 2804754


Reply  Return-To-Index  
 
Msg ID: 2804758 Didn’t airlog or phi loose a 76 years ago hitting (NT) +0/-1     
Author:Plastic windshield
2/4/2024 2:13:56 PM

Reply to: 2804749


Reply  Return-To-Index  
 
Msg ID: 2804774 Here's what happened... +7/-0     
Author:Lesson Learned
2/4/2024 7:57:26 PM

Reply to: 2804749

It was in January of 2009.  PHI, in their quest to decrease the empty weight of their S-76's and increase their useful load, took out the heavy glass windscreens and replaced them with an acrylic substitute.  Cruising along at 700' agl and 135 knots, a crew ran into a flock of birds.  The windscreen was compromised and at least one bird came into the cockpit and knocked *both* of the fire handles back, which brought the ECL levers back and out of "Fly."  We, who were not there, can only imagine the noise, chaos and confustion that overwhelmed the unfortunate crew who had just six seconds to trouble-shoot and react.  That S-76 did not have a "Low Rotor" horn.  Apparently, the crew did not get the pitch down in time, lost rotor rpm and crashed into the marsh.  Everyone perished.  Very sad accident.



Reply  Return-To-Index  
 
Msg ID: 2804828 Here's what happened... +2/-1     
Author:Learned the hard way
2/5/2024 8:38:43 PM

Reply to: 2804774

Phi wasn't the only operator that was using plastic windshields for the reasons listed above. Crews expressed their concerns about it but they turned a deaf ear. It's terrible that a tragedy like this forced them to put he glass windows back in but had it not happen the operators would have never gone back to glass. 



Reply  Return-To-Index  
 
Msg ID: 2804836 Here's what happened... +1/-1     
Author:Fact Checker
2/6/2024 6:33:38 AM

Reply to: 2804774

Read the NTSB full report.  A single bird, not a flock. And there was no evidence that the bird penetrated the windscreen.  Other factors associated with the throttle design contributed.

A very tragic accident for those on board and their families.



Reply  Return-To-Index  
 
Msg ID: 2804853 Here's what happened... +2/-0     
Author:TR
2/6/2024 11:19:33 AM

Reply to: 2804836

If the windscreen was glass it would have provided enough structual integrity to deflect the bird. The plastic folded up and allowed the centerpost to collapse. 



Reply  Return-To-Index  
 
Msg ID: 2805267 Here's what happened... +0/-0     
Author:ACTUALLY
2/13/2024 6:10:01 PM

Reply to: 2804853

Plastic windshields were installed at customer's request.

I was there.



Reply  Return-To-Index  
 
Msg ID: 2804871 Here's what happened... +0/-4     
Author:Jeezus Louiseus
2/6/2024 8:07:40 PM

Reply to: 2804836

Person: "The sky is blue."

Helicopter pilot: "NO IT ISN'T!  It's actually cyan. Or sometimes bluish purple. I was my unit's Meteorological Officer for six months in the military, and I studied..."  

God, I hate helicopter pilots. Always, always contrary. Always. It must be in their DNA - this neurotic obsession to always be right and let everyone know it.

Okay, NTSB report on PHI's S-76:

1)  About 7 minutes after departure, the cockpit voice recorder recorded a loud bang, followed by sounds consistent with rushing wind and a power reduction on both engines and a decay of main rotor revolutions per minute.

2)  Examination of the wreckage revealed that both the left and right sections of the cast acrylic windshield were shattered. Feathers and other bird remains were collected from the canopy and windshield at the initial point of impact and from other locations on the exterior of the helicopter. 

"Other locations on the exterior?" Whaaat? Gee, sounds like maybe more than one bird to me. But whether it was a single bird or a flock does not matter.  One bird is all it took.  It hit the canopy, perfectly centered, I guess, at the top of the windscreens and broke BOTH of them sufficiently that there were holes big enough to allow air to rush in and push BOTH fire handles back - *and* knocked both "throttles" out of their detents. Definitely not a parakeet.

So, fine, play your stupid little semantic, nit-picky, I'm-smarter-than-you game of, "There was no evidence that the bird penetrated the windscreen." Right, the hole(s) in the shattered windscreens were caused by something else. My bad.



Reply  Return-To-Index  
 
Msg ID: 2804874 Here's what happened... +3/-1     
Author:Pot
2/6/2024 9:00:01 PM

Reply to: 2804871

meet kettle.



Reply  Return-To-Index  
 
Msg ID: 2804886 Here's what happened... +3/-4     
Author:How about
2/6/2024 11:28:35 PM

Reply to: 2804874
Let's stop flying at 500agl when it is clear out. Especially at night. You guys are not being shot at. There is no need to be cruising this low. A needless loss of life. Very sad.


Reply  Return-To-Index  
 
Msg ID: 2804897 Here's what happened... +0/-3     
Author:Heli pilot
2/7/2024 7:47:33 AM

Reply to: 2804886

What would be your suggestion for a min altitude en route, pray tell?  Whats the typical altitudes you fly, both day & night?



Reply  Return-To-Index  
 
Msg ID: 2804938 Here's what happened... +0/-2     
Author:according to the FAA
2/7/2024 9:23:42 PM

Reply to: 2804886

90% of the bird strikes occur below 3000 AGL.  Most EMS enroute altitudes are below 3000 AGL.

Your turn.



Reply  Return-To-Index  
 
Msg ID: 2804907 never seen a flock of red-tailed hawks... (NT) +3/-1     
Author:just sayin'
2/7/2024 11:32:25 AM

Reply to: 2804871


Reply  Return-To-Index  
 
Msg ID: 2804940 never seen a flock of red-tailed hawks... +0/-1     
Author:Heli pilot
2/7/2024 10:43:54 PM

Reply to: 2804907

Point taken.  



Reply  Return-To-Index  
 
Msg ID: 2805018 never seen red-tailed hawk move out of YOUR way either! (NT) +0/-1     
Author:Nor Bald Eagles, V-Tail Kites or Osprey
2/9/2024 12:02:25 PM

Reply to: 2804940


Reply  Return-To-Index  
 
Msg ID: 2805021 That is because they are called a Kettle of Hawks (NT) +0/-1     
Author:not a "flock of hawks"
2/9/2024 12:08:03 PM

Reply to: 2804907


Reply  Return-To-Index  
 
Msg ID: 2804942 Here's what happened... +0/-1     
Author:poor bob
2/8/2024 7:20:41 AM

Reply to: 2804871

hates to be corrected. shatters his delusion



Reply  Return-To-Index  
 
Msg ID: 2804948 Here's what happened... +0/-1     
Author:lol bon
2/8/2024 9:15:43 AM

Reply to: 2804871

"this neurotic obsession to always be right and let everyone know it"

 

the lack of self awareness here is amazing.



Reply  Return-To-Index  
 
Msg ID: 2805005 Fly low... pay high…. 500 feet at night. Idiots. (NT) +0/-1     
Author:All dead from
2/9/2024 10:30:39 AM

Reply to: 2804948


Reply  Return-To-Index  
 
Msg ID: 2805019 Could have happened at the altitude you suggest too! Idiots. (NT) +0/-1     
Author:(speaking of...)
2/9/2024 12:03:36 PM

Reply to: 2805005


Reply  Return-To-Index  
 
Msg ID: 2805055 Could have happened at the altitude you suggest too! Idiots.  +0/-1     
Author:but much more likely
2/10/2024 6:55:35 AM

Reply to: 2805019

at his low altitude, which is the point and why faa wants you higher bro



Reply  Return-To-Index  
 
Msg ID: 2805073 and, as you are admitting, can happen at any altitude (NT) +0/-0     
Author:Anonymous
2/10/2024 12:46:39 PM

Reply to: 2805055


Reply  Return-To-Index  
 
Msg ID: 2805033 who remembers this bird strike?? +0/-1     
Author:Canada Geese....
2/9/2024 4:32:09 PM

Reply to: 2804672
At 3:27:11, during climbout, the plane struck a flock of Canada geese at an altitude of 2,818 feet (859 m) about 4.5 miles (7.2 km) north-northwest of LaGuardia. The pilots' view was filled with the large birds;[24][25] passengers and crew heard very loud bangs and saw flames from the engines, followed by silence and an odor of fuel.[26][27][28] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/US_Airways_Flight_1549


Reply  Return-To-Index