Click here to close
New Message Alert
List Entire Thread
Msg ID: 2782895 Helicopter pilot  +12/-6     
Author:Facts
5/14/2023 2:44:30 PM

Only inexperienced pilots with zero twin time and zero actual IMC time advocate a light single is safer / better than a twin doing SPIFR Ops. 

ill take a 429 or 145 even a 135 over a 119 going IMC

and if you want a 407 over those options above your flat out retarded 



Reply  Return-To-Index  
 
Msg ID: 2782897 Helicopter pilot  +1/-3     
Author:MEH
5/14/2023 3:34:32 PM

Reply to: 2782895

Who cares.  Flying is flying.  



Reply  Return-To-Index  
 
Msg ID: 2782904 Helicopter pilot  +2/-5     
Author:Retired
5/14/2023 4:29:55 PM

Reply to: 2782895

Fact man should compare accident stats. before giving "facts" regarding 407.  Fact man sounds like a medical type and or a robi-ranger.



Reply  Return-To-Index  
 
Msg ID: 2782976 Helicopter pilot  +1/-1     
Author:lots of airplanes fly
5/14/2023 10:48:57 PM

Reply to: 2782907

single engine IFR every day. tell me again about all your experience bro



Reply  Return-To-Index  
 
Msg ID: 2782985 Helicopter pilot  +0/-1     
Author:Oh that’s right
5/14/2023 11:41:05 PM

Reply to: 2782976

Helicopters are so much like airplanes



Reply  Return-To-Index  
 
Msg ID: 2782992 Helicopter pilot  +4/-1     
Author:Old azz flyer
5/15/2023 1:03:37 AM

Reply to: 2782895

IIMC is still inadvertent. I'd guess most of those crashes it really wouldn't matter what was being flown. Between panic or the typical lowering of altitude to get below the clouds that seems common would still be a pilot error crash.

I'm sure someone will find one, but I dont know of one crash that was attributed to an engine failure in IMC that a second engine would have made any difference.



Reply  Return-To-Index  
 
Msg ID: 2783031 Helicopter pilot  +0/-2     
Author:Slug
5/15/2023 11:27:59 AM

Reply to: 2782992

It's all about profit margin.  If you have the demand for twin, there will be a supply.  IFR/VFR, I mush rather have a twin (barring cost prohibitions) just in casse there is that single engine failure, compressor stall, Hi side/Low side FADEC failure.  But I also understand economics and running a single isn't cheap either.  Especially for those tree-fiddy workers.



Reply  Return-To-Index  
 
Msg ID: 2783053 Helicopter pilot  +0/-0     
Author:olderendirt
5/15/2023 3:59:11 PM

Reply to: 2783031

It's all about profit margin.  If you have the demand for twin, there will be a supply.  IFR/VFR, I mush rather have a twin (barring cost prohibitions) just in casse there is that single engine failure, compressor stall, Hi side/Low side FADEC failure.  But I also understand economics and running a single isn't cheap either.  Especially for those tree-fiddy workers.

Multis are generally more complicated even with modern systems- systems fail and often confuse the pilot. I'll argue that the advantage of a twin only applies in operations that understand the difference. Single engines are simpler to train and operate, without question. A single engine attitude in a twin results in stupid mistakes, typified by a newly qualified twin pilots' statement "I have two engines, I can fly in any speed/altitude/load condition I want to as long as I'm less than max gross..."

I flew a program with three twins assigned to the contract. In a fligh to base, light, an aircraft had a low side falure with only one passenger who had THOUSANDS of hours in twins with an overseas operator, who attempted to persuade the PIC not to reduce the good engines' power lever. In the water well short of the beach. The FAR minimum training time and flight test standards, I believe resulted in a poor understanding of identifying the issue.



Reply  Return-To-Index  
 
Msg ID: 2783035 Helicopter pilot  +4/-4     
Author:New IP Guy
5/15/2023 11:45:57 AM

Reply to: 2782992

I am all for twins, but without exception the ones that demand twins have never had an engine failure, let alone in IMC.

Of course I am discounting any engine failures that the pilot caused without having enough fuel, or oil. Or even leaving the fuel cap or oil cap off.



Reply  Return-To-Index  
 
Msg ID: 2783747 Helicopter pilot  +0/-0     
Author:blade_slap
5/26/2023 12:23:33 AM

Reply to: 2782895

why the gripe OP?



Reply  Return-To-Index