Click here to close
New Message Alert
List Entire Thread
Msg ID: 2732096 Encouraging pilots to not pick up overtime during negotiations is illegal +0/-7     
Author:Some reading materials for the stall
6/12/2022 12:50:20 AM

https://www.law360.com/articles/79557/pilots-no-overtime-campaign-illegal-aa>

 

https://www.wsj.com/articles/SB980736740965129659?mod=trending_now_video_3</p>

 

https://www.reuters.com/article/labor-injunction/union-cant-encourage-pilot-work-slowdown-during-contract-talks-d-c-circuit-idUSL2N2461A8

 

https://www.avweb.com/recent-updates/business-military/spirit-pilots-declining-to-work-overtime/

 

https://www.dallasnews.com/business/local-companies/2019/08/12/american-airlines-wins-trial-over-mechanics-in-work-slowdown-case/

 

https://news.bloomberglaw.com/daily-labor-report/court-finds-illegal-slowdown-at-us-airways-grants-preliminary-injunction-against-union

 

>https://www.twu.org/aa-update-court-issues-permanent-injunction/

&nbsp;

https://www.courthousenews.com/airline-wins-injunction/

 

<p>Tired yet?   It's ILLEGAL!



Return-To-Index  
 
Msg ID: 2732099 Encouraging pilots to not pick up overtime during negotiations is illegal (NT) +1/-0     
Author:Only By Parties To The Negotiation
6/12/2022 1:33:14 AM

Reply to: 2732096


Return-To-Index  
 
Msg ID: 2732124 or when Unions don't intervene condemning the message (NT) +1/-0     
Author:and stopping the rouge unionists
6/12/2022 9:10:34 AM

Reply to: 2732099


Return-To-Index  
 
Msg ID: 2732149 or when Unions don't intervene condemning the message +2/-0     
Author:Rogue, Like The X-Men Super
6/12/2022 4:29:03 PM

Reply to: 2732124

Hero. There is no rouge X-Men super hero. He/She would be all red, or a cast member of moulin rouge.



Return-To-Index  
 
Msg ID: 2732104 Encouraging pilots to not pick up overtime during negotiations is illegal +5/-1     
Author:STD trash
6/12/2022 2:17:06 AM

Reply to: 2732096
So is massive ballot box stuffing. What’s your point?


Return-To-Index  
 
Msg ID: 2732107 Everyone's selfish! +1/-0     
Author:Anonymous
6/12/2022 7:10:40 AM

Reply to: 2732096

It's whether you are selfish and smart or selfish and dumb. A stooge that works at cross-purposes to collective bargaining is selfish and dumb.



Return-To-Index  
 
Msg ID: 2732125 and profitable since the overtime is plentiful! (NT) +0/-0     
Author:Anonymous
6/12/2022 9:11:51 AM

Reply to: 2732107


Return-To-Index  
 
Msg ID: 2732142 Fantastic! +1/-0     
Author:Anonymous
6/12/2022 1:08:35 PM

Reply to: 2732125
Thanks to you, sooner or later, everyone else will break down and return. Then everyone, including and especially you, will make a fraction of what they could be making. Cooperation increases wages. Cutthroat competition reduces them.


Return-To-Index  
 
Msg ID: 2732143 It's called Status Quo pal, Status Quo! (NT) +0/-0     
Author:Anonymous
6/12/2022 1:28:48 PM

Reply to: 2732142


Return-To-Index  
 
Msg ID: 2732150 and profitable since the overtime is plentiful! +0/-0     
Author:You Can Maximize The Profitable
6/12/2022 4:32:31 PM

Reply to: 2732125

Aspect of your position by taking open shifts every day you are scheduled off, and never taking sick, personal, or vacation days. 



Return-To-Index  
 
Msg ID: 2732152 Or…CUT unneeded management and their bonuses. Worthless investment (NT) +2/-0     
Author:Waaay too much management and overpaid
6/12/2022 4:36:44 PM

Reply to: 2732150


Return-To-Index  
 
Msg ID: 2732110 NOT illegal. A violation during certain points of the process AND +8/-0     
Author:ONLY by parties to agreement
6/12/2022 7:22:12 AM

Reply to: 2732096

Stop trying to scare people 



Return-To-Index  
 
Msg ID: 2732126 You don't read very well! No wonder you don't (NT) +0/-0     
Author:negotiate contracts worth the paper
6/12/2022 9:12:51 AM

Reply to: 2732110


Return-To-Index  
 
Msg ID: 2732115 Encouraging pilots to not pick up overtime during negotiations is illegal +1/-1     
Author:If I were you, bro
6/12/2022 7:53:59 AM

Reply to: 2732096

I would call the police and file a report lol



Return-To-Index  
 
Msg ID: 2732117 No. It’s not illegal. STOP trying to scare people AMC management (NT) +1/-1     
Author:Scare tactics don’t work here anymore
6/12/2022 8:27:42 AM

Reply to: 2732115


Return-To-Index  
 
Msg ID: 2732127 Scare, isn't that what you are trying to do? Scare the company (NT) +0/-1     
Author:into complying with your arm twisting?
6/12/2022 9:14:52 AM

Reply to: 2732117


Return-To-Index  
 
Msg ID: 2732135 Encouraging pilots to not pick up overtime during negotiations is illegal +1/-0     
Author:AMC #5
6/12/2022 11:06:31 AM

Reply to: 2732096

Maybe post this to the union board, or are you scared because you can't complain anonymously on there. 
don't be a coward. 



Return-To-Index  
 
Msg ID: 2732139 Union itself needs to do it, so it's officially discouraged (NT) +0/-0     
Author:Otherwise, it's tacit approval
6/12/2022 12:32:26 PM

Reply to: 2732135


Return-To-Index  
 
Msg ID: 2732140 Union came here to secretly promote this (NT) +0/-0     
Author:So this is where it is countered
6/12/2022 12:37:28 PM

Reply to: 2732135


Return-To-Index  
 
Msg ID: 2732188 Encouraging pilots to not pick up overtime during negotiations is illegal +0/-1     
Author:And what
6/12/2022 11:21:25 PM

Reply to: 2732135

I wonder, would the union do to a member that is pointing out a valid claim of illegal activity by the union and/or its members?  Is it a valid claim or not?  It's irrelevant who is making a claim unless the union intends on some sort of blackmail or strong arm campaign.



Return-To-Index  
 
Msg ID: 2732146 Encouraging pilots to not pick up overtime during negotiations is illegal +1/-0     
Author:Yes, illegal for the union
6/12/2022 4:10:31 PM

Reply to: 2732096

Legal for a pilot to decline voluntary overtime, and legal to tell others pilots why they are doing it



Return-To-Index  
 
Msg ID: 2732151 Again. Where has the union done this? Haven’t seen anything from the union  +2/-1     
Author:On workover or work actions.
6/12/2022 4:33:48 PM

Reply to: 2732146

Stop trying to stir the pot and scare people with your fake news



Return-To-Index  
 
Msg ID: 2732153 Again. Where has the union done this? Haven’t seen anything from the union  +0/-1     
Author:You should work on
6/12/2022 4:42:53 PM

Reply to: 2732151

Reading before replying



Return-To-Index  
 
Msg ID: 2732161 The union is it's pilot's. Anyone telling anyone else (NT) +0/-2     
Author:to do this is Union telling them!
6/12/2022 5:57:38 PM

Reply to: 2732151


Return-To-Index  
 
Msg ID: 2732166 No. No it’s not….or you yourself would be complicit in this act based on (NT) +0/-0     
Author:Your theory and warped reality
6/12/2022 6:31:32 PM

Reply to: 2732161


Return-To-Index  
 
Msg ID: 2732168 Simple facts. Refusing OT to inflict hardship on company (NT) +0/-2     
Author:is ILLEGAL, regardless who call for it!
6/12/2022 6:52:29 PM

Reply to: 2732166


Return-To-Index  
 
Msg ID: 2732170 Simple facts. Refusing OT to inflict hardship on company +0/-0     
Author:No Employee Can Be Coerced
6/12/2022 6:55:29 PM

Reply to: 2732168

Into taking open shifts. Note that open shifts are not the same as overtime. Open shifts are unpredictable and vary widely. Overtime does not.



Return-To-Index  
 
Msg ID: 2732171 What part of “voluntary” do you not understand. Your logic does not apply  +1/-0     
Author:Thanks to the CBA language.
6/12/2022 7:10:22 PM

Reply to: 2732170

Goodbye.



Return-To-Index  
 
Msg ID: 2732179 What part of court orders do you not understand? (NT) +0/-1     
Author:Enjoined!
6/12/2022 9:00:31 PM

Reply to: 2732171


Return-To-Index  
 
Msg ID: 2732182 What part of court orders do you not understand? +1/-0     
Author:Court
6/12/2022 9:38:20 PM

Reply to: 2732179

Court ordered overtim?

It is voluntary overtime.

Are you feeling ok?

It is pretty simple. Voluntary Overtime. 

I am not participating in voluntary overtime. The court can't force me to work overtime. 



Return-To-Index  
 
Msg ID: 2732157 Nope! A pilot is a union member. Thus, one pilot telling another not to +0/-1     
Author:pickup OT is same as "union" telling
6/12/2022 5:51:42 PM

Reply to: 2732146
The Union (and all its members) are barred from attempting to organize a work slow down. You are in STATUS QUO! The amounts of OT being picked up system wide should not change. The fact that it changes coupled with pilot's telling other pilot's NOT to take any OT is a violation of STATUS QUO! Doesn't matter who's telling pilot's to do that! Unions are OBLIGATED to tell their pilots to continue on as normal (ie, Statue Quo) during negotiations, which began the moment union sent their Section 6 notice. Otherwise, it would be OK for someone to tell the company to ignore other norms they have been doing! They can play your silly game too if they wanted to stoop down to your level!


Return-To-Index  
 
Msg ID: 2732159 Nope! A pilot is a union member. Thus, one pilot telling another not to +3/-0     
Author:Status Quo
6/12/2022 5:55:01 PM

Reply to: 2732157

Yes, status quo. Overtime is voluntary.  



Return-To-Index  
 
Msg ID: 2732163 Statistically voluntarily! If, historically, they been paying X amount (NT) +0/-1     
Author:of OT1 each payday, it shouldn't change
6/12/2022 6:04:06 PM

Reply to: 2732159


Return-To-Index  
 
Msg ID: 2732160 Nope! A pilot is a union member. Thus, one pilot telling another not to +3/-0     
Author:Picking Up Shifts Is Not Status Quo
6/12/2022 5:55:59 PM

Reply to: 2732157

Picking up shifts is unpredictable, and varies widely. Status quo applies to normal scheduled workdays. Non negotiating parties are free to encourage or discourage unscheduled pickup of open shifts.



Return-To-Index  
 
Msg ID: 2732165 Nope! A pilot is a union member. Thus, one pilot telling another not to +0/-0     
Author:Status Quo
6/12/2022 6:19:08 PM

Reply to: 2732160

OT is voluntary.  



Return-To-Index  
 
Msg ID: 2732167 Unfortunately, it is: +0/-2     
Author: Just STOP with your illegal campaign
6/12/2022 6:39:03 PM

Reply to: 2732160

And, any _real_ transportation union (with _real_ RLA experience) knows this:

 

The district court properly determined that Delta's pilots were engaged in an unlawful no-overtime campaign. However, the district court improperly interpreted the gravity and depth of ALPA's duty under the RLA to prevent such an unlawful job action. Because there has been no showing that ALPA lacks control over the pilots, reason dictates that ALPA has not done enough to fulfill its statutorily mandated duty to "maintain" the agreement and avoid an "interruption to commerce." Upon remand, the district court shall issue appropriate injunctive relief directing ALPA to take further steps to end the pilots' no-overtime campaign.

https://law.justia.com/cases/federal/appellate-courts/F3/238/1300/515379/span>

 

 

"It is illegal under the Railway Labor Act for airline employees to go on strike without following a complicated set of rules under federal oversight. Even lesser forms of protest, such as widespread efforts to turn down overtime, are against federal rules, McBryde said."

https://www.dallasnews.com/business/local-companies/2019/08/12/american-airlines-wins-trial-over-mechanics-in-work-slowdown-case/

 

&nbsp;

"On May 20, 2019, plaintiff initiated this action by filing its complaint. Doc. 1. Plaintiff alleged: To gain leverage in contract negotiations, defendants' members changed their behavior in a concerted fashion by, for example, taking an unusual amount of time to repair aircraft and refusing to work overtime 

 

https://casetext.com/case/am-airlines-inc-v-transp-workers-union-of-am-1>

 



Return-To-Index  
 
Msg ID: 2732169 Unfortunately, it is: voluntary overtime  +4/-0     
Author:Voluntary Overtime
6/12/2022 6:55:20 PM

Reply to: 2732167

It is simple. I will shorten it for you.  Voluntary Overtime.  

Voluntary. Done, given, or acting of one's own free will "we are funded by voluntary contributions"

Overtime. Time in addition to what is normal, as time worked beyond one's scheduled working hours."fewer opportunities for overtime"

I am choosing not to do voluntary overtime.  



Return-To-Index  
 
Msg ID: 2732198 Status Quo Overtime!! The data proves it! +0/-1     
Author:Courts Issue TRO and fine unions!
6/13/2022 7:24:02 AM

Reply to: 2732169

You are on this public forum encouraging pilot conduct themselves ILLEGALLY!   STOP IT!

 

https://thepointsguy.com/news/american-airlines-scores-a-court-victory-as-battle-with-mechanics-drags-on/

 



Return-To-Index  
 
Msg ID: 2732205 Status Quo Overtime!! The data proves it! +2/-0     
Author:OT is voluntary
6/13/2022 7:41:59 AM

Reply to: 2732198

All I am doing is stating a fact.

That fact is that overtime is voluntary.  

You might not like that fact, but it doesn't change that fact. 

Overtime is voluntary.  That's the fact.

 

 



Return-To-Index  
 
Msg ID: 2732208 And also fact: Union's have been fined for discouraging OT during (NT) +0/-0     
Author:negotiations. It's bad faith bargaining
6/13/2022 7:49:31 AM

Reply to: 2732205


Return-To-Index  
 
Msg ID: 2732220 Voting with my feet +1/-0     
Author:No problem
6/13/2022 10:19:49 AM

Reply to: 2732208

I am not working or doing overtime.

I voted already with my feet. 



Return-To-Index  
 
Msg ID: 2732257 ALL of those references involved mandatory overtime NOT voluntary! (NT) +0/-0     
Author:Read much…
6/13/2022 2:44:22 PM

Reply to: 2732208


Return-To-Index  
 
Msg ID: 2732234 Status Quo Overtime!! The data proves it! +0/-0     
Author:I see
6/13/2022 12:05:55 PM

Reply to: 2732205

someone is starting to see the error of their boisterous opinion.



Return-To-Index  
 
Msg ID: 2732250 Courts say it is illegal and that air carriers can seek injuctive +0/-0     
Author:relief against individual pilots
6/13/2022 1:27:13 PM

Reply to: 2732234

https://law.justia.com/cases/federal/appellate-courts/F3/238/1300/515379/p>

 

Delta Air Lines, Inc., Plaintiff-appellant, v. Air Line Pilots Association, International, et al., Defendants-appellees, 238 F.3d 1300 (11th Cir. 2001) 

 
U.S. Court of Appeals for the Eleventh Circuit - 238 F.3d 1300 (11th Cir. 2001)January 18, 2001

 

"The district court properly determined that Delta's pilots were engaged in an unlawful no-overtime campaign. However, the district court improperly interpreted the gravity and depth of ALPA's duty under the RLA to prevent such an unlawful job action. Because there has been no showing that ALPA lacks control over the pilots, reason dictates that ALPA has not done enough to fulfill its statutorily mandated duty to "maintain" the agreement and avoid an "interruption to commerce." Upon remand, the district court shall issue appropriate injunctive relief directing ALPA to take further steps to end the pilots' no-overtime campaign. Further steps may include issuing directives as drafted by the court and threatening (or imposing) union sanctions for violations, as permitted by ALPA's constitution.25  If ALPA complies with the court's orders and the no-overtime campaign continues, Delta may return to the district court for injunctive relief against individual pilots, as discussed supra Part III.C."

 

If the pre-Section 6 negotiation notice was that there was normally X amount of overtime being taken up by pilots, then to maintain STATUS QUO, the number X should not change.  Furthermore, the Union has a statutoryily mandated duty to maintain the pre-Section 6 notice norms or find itself being sanctioned by the court.   Particulary, if there is evidence of any concerted effort to pursuade pilots not to work overtime to "put a hurt" on the company, as we've seen here already.

You don't have to be a lawyer to understand this!   You just have to be an intellectually honest individual!



Return-To-Index  
 
Msg ID: 2732253 OT is voluntary (NT) +1/-0     
Author:Voluntary overtime is not mandatory
6/13/2022 1:49:39 PM

Reply to: 2732250


Return-To-Index  
 
Msg ID: 2732255 Simply not applicable. Courts also say you’re mentally incompetent (NT) +0/-0     
Author:Yet here you are
6/13/2022 2:39:25 PM

Reply to: 2732250


Return-To-Index  
 
Msg ID: 2732260 Courts say it is illegal and that air carriers can seek injuctive +0/-0     
Author:Overtime Is Different Than Open
6/13/2022 3:25:07 PM

Reply to: 2732250

Shift.



Return-To-Index  
 
Msg ID: 2732265 Workover and Overtime are different. Voluntary is indisputable. (NT) +0/-0     
Author:Bring it on….no one’s scared
6/13/2022 3:51:07 PM

Reply to: 2732260


Return-To-Index  
 
Msg ID: 2732269 Appears that YOU are the only one making threats and using scare tactics (NT) +0/-0     
Author:FYI…it’s not working. It won’t
6/13/2022 4:23:01 PM

Reply to: 2732250


Return-To-Index  
 
Msg ID: 2732270 Shift coverage on s overtime. Overtime is voluntary. (NT) +0/-0     
Author:Should ft coverage is overtime.
6/13/2022 5:01:15 PM

Reply to: 2732269


Return-To-Index  
 
Msg ID: 2732271 Like the court ruling said, open time is voluntary  +0/-0     
Author:Just like workover I voluntarily
6/13/2022 5:18:00 PM

Reply to: 2732270
The fact you need to come here and tell (advocate/sell) pilot's the need to change their behavior 5o not puck up any more workovers to get some leverage on the company is exactly the same behavior that earned ALPA DELTP pilot's the court injunction above. It is ILLEGAL for you or anyone to attempt to change the norm, it is a form of a strike/work slowdown when you are in STATUS QUO. It is not STATUS QUO calling for behavior changes! Because you are calling for an organized effort here, violates Article 8 of the CBA, which clearly states you can't and you can be terminated without any right to grievance protections for attempting to organize a slowdown. And, that penalty is supported in the Delta vs ALPA court ring above also. Section 8.1 Neither the Union or any of its agents (stewards) nor any of its members will collectively, concertedly, or in any manner engage in a strike, sick-out, boycott, sympathy strike, slow down or work stoppage of any kind during the term of this Agreement. During the term of this Agreement, the Company agrees not to lock out any of the employees covered by this Agreement. It is further understood that the duly-authorized representatives of the Union shall use their best efforts on behalf of the Union to actively encourage the employees engaging in a violation of this Section to cease such conduct. If the Company knows one of its Customers will have a primary picket line, the Company will notify the Pilot before dispatching the Pilot to the location. A Pilot may refuse to take an assignment to cross a picket line if he has reasonable safety concerns based on verifiable incidents of picket line misconduct at the site. In such cases, the Company reserves the right to meet Customer needs however it deems appropriate. Section 8.2 Employees found to be in violation of the terms of this Section shall be subject to discharge. Such discharge shall not be subject to the grievance procedure or System Board of Adjustment and Arbitration provisions of this Agreement, except as to the question of whether the Pilot engaged in such a violation


Return-To-Index  
 
Msg ID: 2732273 Like the court ruling said, open time is voluntary  +0/-0     
Author:Voluntary
6/13/2022 5:25:29 PM

Reply to: 2732271

Fact.  Overtime is voluntary. 



Return-To-Index  
 
Msg ID: 2732274 So is Open Time in the airlines, yet ALPA was cited for  +0/-0     
Author:their ILLEGAL No Open Time campaign
6/13/2022 5:48:14 PM

Reply to: 2732273
It is illegal to tell pilot's what you are telling them! Status Quo means contine as normal, which is established as pilot's picking up workover at a specific rate. If that rate drops, particularly after your "don't work any extra shifts" message, then you are committing BAD FAITH NEGOTIATIONS. You said above that the company was violating status quo, but you haven't once gave a single example of it to justify that statement.


Return-To-Index  
 
Msg ID: 2732277 Still waiting for you to post the communication from the union calling 4  +0/-0     
Author:Any work stoppage or work action
6/13/2022 6:18:22 PM

Reply to: 2732271

Oh yeah....it doesn't exist Because they have not. it's all in your fragile little mind. 



Return-To-Index  
 
Msg ID: 2732282 Just look here! Been posted several times. Union is obligated for  +0/-0     
Author:to tell its members otherwise!
6/13/2022 6:46:05 PM

Reply to: 2732277
A hush hush campaign is still a campaign! Union is obligated to tell its pilot's otherwise.


Return-To-Index  
 
Msg ID: 2732276 So is your mom….. see (NT) +1/-0     
Author:No one cares
6/13/2022 6:16:06 PM

Reply to: 2732096


Return-To-Index  
 
Msg ID: 2732291 Work over shift coverage overtime  +0/-0     
Author:All voluntary
6/13/2022 7:59:07 PM

Reply to: 2732276

Why don't you like facts?  

I don't have to work anymore than my scheduled shifts.  

Work over, shift coverage and overtime are voluntary. 

I am just stating facts.  



Return-To-Index  
 
Msg ID: 2732293 the stall is the appropriate place +2/-0     
Author:for your post
6/13/2022 8:18:29 PM

Reply to: 2732096

It is not illegal to refuse to work overtime.

It is not illegal to discuss why you are not working overtime.

Your citations refer to are union sanctioned work slowdowns, and overtime refusals.



Return-To-Index  
 
Msg ID: 2732370 Encouraging pilots to not pick up overtime during negotiations is illegal +1/-0     
Author:Encouraging it may be,
6/14/2022 4:24:24 PM

Reply to: 2732096

but simply not doing it, like I have always chosen, is not.

Lifeis for living, not sitting around at a base twiddling thumbs (demoralizing too).



Return-To-Index  
 
Msg ID: 2732376 And, that is encouraging it. You are in Status Quo, so (NT) +0/-1     
Author:there shouldn't be any hint to do it!
6/14/2022 5:16:21 PM

Reply to: 2732370


Return-To-Index  
 
Msg ID: 2732389 Voluntary overtime (NT) +0/-0     
Author:Is voluntary
6/14/2022 6:55:00 PM

Reply to: 2732376


Return-To-Index  
 
Msg ID: 2732438 Status quo +1/-1     
Author:Status quo
6/15/2022 10:50:00 AM

Reply to: 2732389

Status quo.  Overtime, shift coverage and work over have been voluntary and still are voluntary. 



Return-To-Index  
 
Msg ID: 2732507 And, that is encouraging it. You are in Status Quo, so +0/-0     
Author:King
6/15/2022 7:59:23 PM

Reply to: 2732376

of obfuscation and double-triple not-think - aka garbage...



Return-To-Index  
 
Msg ID: 2732514 Status Quo +0/-0     
Author:So
6/15/2022 8:31:39 PM

Reply to: 2732507

Stating a fact is encouraging what?   Overtime is voluntary.  It might encourage someone to do overtime. 



Return-To-Index  
 
Msg ID: 2732909 Encouraging pilots to not pick up overtime during negotiations is illegal +0/-0     
Author:So?
6/19/2022 2:29:13 AM

Reply to: 2732096

These days everything is illegal - welcome to utopian marxland.



Return-To-Index